On War
War—the subject is complex and simple. Is it good? No. Is it always bad? Yes. Is it ever necessary? Sometimes. It’s the “sometimes” element that has challenged and perplexed people over the centuries. Societies have raised classes of people whose role was to be warriors, to fight and die for the tribe, city, or country. Hoplite armies became Legions; legions gave way to feudal knights, and feudal hosts gave way to professional armies. Armies are not the issue, though. Carl von Clausewitz, in his analysis of Napoleonic warfare, wrote of the “fascinating Trinity” at work in modern war: violent emotion, the interplay of probability and chance, and reason, based on a political motive. All of that lies in the realm of society or the nation state. For individuals, what are the moral elements a citizen-soldier faces?
Oh, I am so going to get into trouble over this blog item. I can feel it; the sense of foreboding is palpable. But, here goes…
The New York Times published a blog today by Ethan Bronner, entitled “The Bullets In My In-Box,” in which he discusses how a journalist is not allowed to write objectively about any aspect of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Mr. Bronner concludes:
Copyright ©2010 The Pathkeeper. All Rights Reserved.
Site created by James River Technical Communications