September 05, 2010
Text Size

blogging about the worlds in which we live

Woodcut of Britons fighting RomansWar—the subject is complex and simple. Is it good? No. Is it always bad? Yes. Is it ever necessary? Sometimes. It’s the “sometimes” element that has challenged and perplexed people over the centuries. Societies have raised classes of people whose role was to be warriors, to fight and die for the tribe, city, or country. Hoplite armies became Legions; legions gave way to feudal knights, and feudal hosts gave way to professional armies. Armies are not the issue, though.  Carl von Clausewitz, in his analysis of Napoleonic warfare, wrote of the “fascinating Trinity” at work in modern war: violent emotion, the interplay of probability and chance, and reason, based on a political motive. All of that lies in the realm of society or the nation state. For individuals, what are the moral elements a citizen-soldier faces?

Oh, I am so going to get into trouble over this blog item. I can feel it; the sense of foreboding is palpable. But, here goes…

The New York Times published a blog today by Ethan Bronner, entitled “The Bullets In My In-Box,” in which he discusses how a journalist is not allowed to write objectively about any aspect of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Mr. Bronner concludes:

Read more...

Confederate dead at Antietam, 1862
Confederate dead at Antietam

People, especially Southerners, argue amongst themselves over the essential commonality of the “War of Yankee Aggression” (a.k.a. “The Late Unpleasantness” or the “American Civil War”). Some deny that the war was about slavery whilst others declare slavery the reason for the war.

Okay, let’s look at this thing…

Read more...

I’m limiting my discussion to the period of the Second World War in which the United States was a belligerent.
US troops at Omaha Beach
Omaha Beach, June 6, 1944

The United States expended over $341 billion throughout World War II, including $50 billion in Lend-Lease supplies sent to Great Britain ($31 billion), the Soviet Union, China, and 35 other nations. This country suffered an estimated 400,000 casualties, including over 290,000 combat deaths. World-wide, the human cost of the war has been estimated at 50,000,000, including those murdered in the Holocaust. Total expenditures by belligerents have been estimated at $1 trillion, in 1945 dollars.

Read more...

The Continental Congress
The Continental Congress in Philadelphia

Was our American Revolution a Just War?

King George III, his officers, Parliament, and Colonial loyalists considered the Revolution an illegal insurrection, a rebellion against their legitimate government. The leaders of the Revolution considered their acts justified and the war a just action against an illegal tyranny. So, was that war just, in the classical sense?

Read more...

We often hear the phrase “just war” used in connection with, well, any war, including the war on terror in which we are currently engaged. Some may be aware of the theological implications of the words, “just war,” but many, I suspect, are not. Perhaps we should take a few moments to look at how war has been justified in Christian theology for centuries, and how a war can be considered “just.” First, what do we mean by the use of the adjective, just?

Read more...

Content published on Pathkeeper.Net is protected by copyright and may be downloaded or copied only for personal, noncommercial, use. It remains the intellectual property of the author or named contributor and may not be otherwise reproduced or published without the express, written permission.

War Archives

  • Palestine
    Oh, I am so going to get into trouble over this blog item. I can feel it; the sense of foreboding is palpable. But, here goes… The New York Times published a blog today by Ethan Bronner, entitled “ Read More...
  • For What Our Civil War?
    Confederate dead at Antietam People, especially Southerners, argue amongst themselves over the essential commonality of the “War of Yankee Aggression” (a.k.a. “The Late Unpleasantness” or...
    Read More...
  • Was World War II a Just War?
    I’m limiting my discussion to the period of the Second World War in which the United States was a belligerent. Omaha Beach, June 6, 1944 The United States expended over $341 billion throughout...
    Read More...
  • Our American Revolution
    The Continental Congress in Philadelphia Was our American Revolution a Just War? King George III, his officers, Parliament, and Colonial loyalists considered the Revolution an illegal insurrection,...
    Read More...
  • On a Just War
    We often hear the phrase “just war” used in connection with, well, any war, including the war on terror in which we are currently engaged. Some may be aware of the theological implications of the words,...
    Read More...